22 Comments
User's avatar
User's avatar
Comment removed
Oct 19, 2023
Comment removed
Jessica Smock's avatar

I'm not sure if it's brave, but when Julie told us a little bit about her experiences in the comments of a post, I felt like it was a voice that needed to be shared. Julie did such a beautiful job describing her life so vividly at a time of such uncertainty, fear, and resilience.

Erika Dreifus's avatar

An extraordinary piece. Thank you, Julie Zuckerman, for writing it. And thank *you*, MIDSTORY, for publishing it.

Jessica Smock's avatar

Thank you for sharing it as well.

Dana's avatar

Julie, thank you. And I’m so sorry. Steph and Jessica, thank you for amplifying Julie’s voice. I’m in tears reading this in the dark before my Jewish kids go to school in the safety of my home but I don’t feel safe in certain ways and I am in mourning for the losses Julie describes, and the pain that will continue to roll out from this ongoing tragedy.

Julie Zuckerman's avatar

Thank you, Dana. Sending a virtual hug....

Steph Sprenger's avatar

I am sending you so much love daily, my friend.

Jessica Smock's avatar

Sending you much love as well, Dana.

JULIA HIRSCH's avatar

Thank you for sharing this story. There's terror here and heartbreak and catastrophe, but your posting this message also reaffirms all we have, each other, community and the underlying humanity we share. Thank you.

Julie Zuckerman's avatar

Thanks so much, Julia. Indeed - it is the community that helps keep us going...

Claire Freeland's avatar

Beautiful and heart breaking. Sending hugs and strength.

Julie Zuckerman's avatar

Thank you, Claire. Sending hugs and strength back to you.

Amy Wallen's avatar

Thank you for sharing your story. I have been thinking about you every day during this tumultuous time, and hoping you and yours are safe. Wishing for peace sooner rather than later.

Julie Zuckerman's avatar

Thanks so much, Amy. Amen to peace sooner rather than later.

Diane's avatar

Thank you for sharing this, Julie. It is good for the rest of us to understand the pain and trauma you are in from a "real" person not just a random news article. Sending much love and prayers

Julie Zuckerman's avatar

Thank you so much, Diane.

Sari Rosenblatt's avatar

My heart grieves for you, your family, your Friends, All of Israel. Utterly devastating and you really deliver the news and emotion and - yes, yes— all too much- even to read about never mind live the horror. If there ever was an important piece of writing— this is it

Julie Zuckerman's avatar

Thanks Sari. And thanks for reaching out the other day. Sending hugs.

Stephanie Alter Jones's avatar

thank you for sharing both the realities of the moment and the reflection on what's to come. Grace and peace to you all.

Julie Zuckerman's avatar

Thanks so much, Stephanie..

Gayle Chappell's avatar

I am very conflicted. What happened is an abomination. The casual mention of having to live with "safe rooms" to hide from violence highlights to me that people, both Palestinians and Israelis, have been living with violence for a long time. I am not surprised by this desperate violence, although I am deeply saddened. Your stories are being experienced by tens of thousands of people very day now. There is no chicken or toilet paper, no water and no medicine. There is nothing left but rubble and suffering. When will it end?